Based on the discussion in
http://lists.llvm.org/pipermail/llvm-dev/2019-October/135574.html, the
conclusion was reached that the ARM backend should produce vcmp instead
of vcmpe instructions by default, i.e. not be producing an Invalid
Operation exception when either arguments in a floating point compare
are quiet NaNs.
In the future, after constrained floating point intrinsics for floating
point compare have been introduced, vcmpe instructions probably should
be produced for those intrinsics - depending on the exact semantics
they'll be defined to have.
This patch logically consists of the following parts:
- Revert http://llvm.org/viewvc/llvm-project?rev=294945&view=rev and
http://llvm.org/viewvc/llvm-project?rev=294968&view=rev, which
implemented fine-tuning for when to produce vcmpe (i.e. not do it for
equality comparisons). The complexity introduced by those patches
isn't needed anymore if we just always produce vcmp instead. Maybe
these patches need to be reintroduced again once support is needed to
map potential LLVM-IR constrained floating point compare intrinsics to
the ARM instruction set.
- Simply select vcmp, instead of vcmpe, see simple changes in
lib/Target/ARM/ARMInstrVFP.td
- Adapt lots of tests that tested for vcmpe (instead of vcmp). For all
of these test, the intent of what is tested for isn't related to
whether the vcmp should produce an Invalid Operation exception or not.
Fixes PR43374.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D68463
llvm-svn: 374025
This function was not checking for the condition code variants which are
undefined if either input is NaN, so we were missing selection of the VSEL
instruction in some cases when using -fno-honor-nans or -ffast-math.
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D58812
llvm-svn: 355199
When generating a floating point comparison we currently unconditionally
generate VCMPE. This has the sideeffect of setting the cumulative Invalid
bit in FPSCR if any of the operands are QNaN.
It is expected that use of a relational predicate on a QNaN value should
raise Invalid. Quoting from the C standard:
The relational and equality operators support the usual mathematical
relationships between numeric values. For any ordered pair of numeric
values exactly one of relationships the less, greater, equal and is true.
Relational operators may raise the floating-point exception when argument
values are NaNs.
The standard doesn't explicitly state the expectation for equality operators,
but the implication and obvious expectation is that equality operators
should not raise Invalid on a QNaN input, as those predicates are wholly
defined on unordered inputs (to return not equal).
Therefore, add a new operand to ARMISD::FPCMP and FPCMPZ indicating if
QNaN should raise Invalid, and pipe that through to TableGen.
llvm-svn: 294945
Given vsel_cc, op1, op2, since vsel has no LE/LT, to generate vsel for
such selection, it needs to inverse cc and swap op1 and op2. To inverse
cc, both L/G and E bits should be flipped.
llvm-svn: 197615
Kristof Beyls