For code below:
{
r7 = addasl(r3,r0,#2)
r8 = addasl(r3,r2,#2)
r5 = memw(r3+r0<<#2)
r6 = memw(r3+r2<<#2)
}
{
p1 = cmp.gtu(r6,r5)
if (p1.new) memw(r8+#0) = r5
if (p1.new) memw(r7+#0) = r6
}
{
r0 = mux(p1,r2,r4)
}
In packetizer, a new packet is created for the cmp instruction since
there arent enough resources in previous packet. Also it is determined
that the cmp stalls by 2 cycles since it depends on the prior load of r5.
In current packetizer implementation, the predicated store is evaluated
for whether it can go in the same packet as compare, and since the compare
stalls, the stall of the predicated store does not matter and it can go in
the same packet as the cmp. However the predicated store will stall for
more cycles because of its dependence on the addasl instruction and to
avoid that stall we can put it in a new packet.
Improve the packetizer to check if an instruction being added to packet
will stall longer than instruction already in packet and if so create a
new packet.
When checking resources in the post RA scheduler, see if a .new
vector store should be used instead of a regular vector store.
It may not be possible to schedule a regular vector store, but
it may be possible to schedule a .new version. If the correct one
isn't used, then the post RA scheduler may not generate the best
schedule.
If there are multiple uses of the def of COPY/REG_SEQUENCE, set the
latency only if the latencies on all the uses are equal, otherwise set
it to default.
The HexagonVectorCombine pass was moving an instruction
incorrectly, which caused a use in a GEP that was not yet
defined.
HexagonVectorCombine removes a load from a group due to its
dependences, but in realignGroup, the load is processed anyways.
In realignGroup, when determining the maximum alignment, only
those instructions still in the group should be considered.
This reverts commit fd4808887e.
This patch causes gcc to issue a lot of warnings like:
warning: base class ‘class llvm::MCParsedAsmOperand’ should be
explicitly initialized in the copy constructor [-Wextra]
This reverts commit ba07f300c6.
A build-vector sequence is made of pairs: rotate+insert. When constructing
a single vector, this results in a chain of 2*N instructions. The rotate
operation is a permute operation, but the insert uses a multiplication
resource: insert and rotate can execute in the same cycle, but obviously
they cannot operate on the same vector. The original halving idea is still
beneficial since it does allow for insert/rotate overlap, and for hiding
insert's latency.
For vectors with repeating values, old codegen would rotate and insert
every duplicate element. This patch replaces that behavior with a splat
of the most common element, vinsert/vror only occur when needed.
They are the same as for the other HVX vectors, but types need to be
listed explicitly. Also, add a detailed codegen testcase.
Co-authored-by: Abhikrant Sharma <quic_abhikran@quicinc.com>
Adds x-ray support for hexagon to llvm codegen, clang driver,
compiler-rt libs.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D113638
Reapplying this after 543a9ad7c4,
which fixes the leak introduced there.
The Pre-RA VLIWMachineScheduler used by Hexagon is a relatively generic
implementation that would make sense to use on other VLIW targets.
This commit lifts those classes into their own header/source file with the
root VLIWMachineScheduler. I chose this path rather than adding the
strategy et al. into MachineScheduler to avoid bloating the file with other
implementations.
Target-specific behaviors have been captured and replicated through
function overloads.
- Added an overloadable DFAPacketizer creation member function. This is
mainly done for our downstream, which has the capability to override
the DFAPacketizer with custom implementations. This is an upstreamable
TODO on our end. Currently, it always returns the result of
TargetInstrInfo::CreateTargetScheduleState
- Added an extra helper which returns the number of instructions in the
current packet. This is used in our downstream, and may be useful
elsewhere.
- Placed the priority heuristic values into the ConvergingVLIWscheduler
class instead of defining them as local statics in the implementation
- Added a overridable helper in ConvergingVLIWScheduler so that targets
can create their own VLIWResourceModel
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D113150
A masked load or store will load a potentially unknown number of bytes
from a memory location - that is not generally known at compile time.
They do not necessarily load/store the entire vector width, and treating
them as such can lead to incorrect aliasing information (for example, if
the underlying object is smaller than the size of the vector).
This makes sure that the MMO is given an unknown size to represent this.
which is less accurate that "may load/store from up to 16 bytes", but
less incorrect that "will load/store from 16 bytes".
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D113888
Most changes are rewording comments but there are some assertions that I rephrased.
Reviewed By: kparzysz
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D114132
TargetPassConfig::addPass takes a "bool verifyAfter" argument which lets
you skip machine verification after a particular pass. Unfortunately
this is used in generic code in TargetPassConfig itself to skip
verification after a generic pass, only because some previous target-
specific pass damaged the MIR on that specific target. This is bad
because problems in one target cause lack of verification for all
targets.
This patch replaces that mechanism with a new MachineFunction property
called "FailsVerification" which can be set by (usually target-specific)
passes that are known to introduce problems. Later passes can reset it
again if they are known to clean up the previous problems.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D111397
This moves the registry higher in the LLVM library dependency stack.
Every client of the target registry needs to link against MC anyway to
actually use the target, so we might as well move this out of Support.
This allows us to ensure that Support doesn't have includes from MC/*.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D111454
To better reflect the meaning of the now-disambiguated {GlobalValue,
GlobalAlias}::getBaseObject after breaking off GlobalIFunc::getResolverFunction
(D109792), the function is renamed to getAliaseeObject.
As described on D111049, we're trying to remove the <string> dependency from error handling and replace uses of report_fatal_error(const std::string&) with the Twine() variant which can be forward declared.
As described on D111049, we're trying to remove the <string> dependency from error handling and replace uses of report_fatal_error(const std::string&) with the Twine() variant which can be forward declared.
We can use the raw_string_ostream::str() method to perform the implicit flush() and return a reference to the std::string container that we can then wrap inside Twine().
Stop using APInt constructors and methods that were soft-deprecated in
D109483. This fixes all the uses I found in llvm, except for the APInt
unit tests which should still test the deprecated methods.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D110807
Based off a discussion on D110100, we should be avoiding default CostKinds whenever possible.
This initial patch removes them from the 'inner' target implementation callbacks - these should only be used by the main TTI calls, so this should guarantee that we don't cause changes in CostKind by missing it in an inner call. This exposed a few missing arguments in getGEPCost and reduction cost calls that I've cleaned up.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D110242
The code was using getTypeStoreSize to calculate the difference
between consecutive objects. The calculation was incorrect due
to padding that is added between consecutive objects. The
getTypeAllocSize includes the padding amount. For example,
if the type is [19 x i8], the difference between consecutive
objects is 32 bytes, not 19 bytes.
A second case for getTypeAllocSize is needed when computing
the pointer values for the vector accesses. The calculation needs
to account for the padding as well.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D109403
Soft deprecrate isNullValue/isAllOnesValue and update in tree
callers. This matches the changes to the APInt interface from
D109483.
Reviewed By: lattner
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D109535
On some architectures such as Arm and X86 the encoding for a nop may
change depending on the subtarget in operation at the time of
encoding. This change replaces the per module MCSubtargetInfo retained
by the targets AsmBackend in favour of passing through the local
MCSubtargetInfo in operation at the time.
On Arm using the architectural NOP instruction can have a performance
benefit on some implementations.
For Arm I've deleted the copy of the AsmBackend's MCSubtargetInfo to
limit the chances of this causing problems in the future. I've not
done this for other targets such as X86 as there is more frequent use
of the MCSubtargetInfo and it looks to be for stable properties that
we would not expect to vary per function.
This change required threading STI through MCNopsFragment and
MCBoundaryAlignFragment.
I've attempted to take into account the in tree experimental backends.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45962
In preparation for passing the MCSubtargetInfo (STI) through to writeNops
so that it can use the STI in operation at the time, we need to record the
STI in operation when a MCAlignFragment may write nops as padding. The
STI is currently unused, a further patch will pass it through to
writeNops.
There are many places that can create an MCAlignFragment, in most cases
we can find out the STI in operation at the time. In a few places this
isn't possible as we are in initialisation or finalisation, or are
emitting constant pools. When possible I've tried to find the most
appropriate existing fragment to obtain the STI from, when none is
available use the per module STI.
For constant pools we don't actually need to use EmitCodeAlign as the
constant pools are data anyway so falling through into it via an
executable NOP is no better than falling through into data padding.
This is a prerequisite for D45962 which uses the STI to emit the
appropriate NOP for the STI. Which can differ per fragment.
Note that involves an interface change to InitSections. It is now
called initSections and requires a SubtargetInfo as a parameter.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45961
The backend generally uses 64-bit immediates (e.g. what
MachineOperand::getImm() returns), so use that for analyzeCompare()
and optimizeCompareInst() as well. This avoids truncation for
targets that support immediates larger 32-bit. In particular, we
can avoid the bugprone value normalization hack in the AArch64
target.
This is a followup to D108076.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D108875
AttributeList::hasAttribute() is confusing, use clearer methods like
hasParamAttr()/hasRetAttr().
Add hasRetAttr() since it was missing from AttributeList.
I'm not sure this is the best way to approach this,
but the situation is rather not very detectable unless we explicitly call it out when refusing to advise to unroll.
Reviewed By: efriedma
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D107271
Pulled out the OptimizationLevel class from PassBuilder in order to be able to access it from within the PassManager and avoid include conflicts.
Reviewed By: mtrofin
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D107025
[[noreturn]] can be used since Oct 2016 when the minimum compiler requirement was bumped to GCC 4.8/MSVC 2015.
Note: the definition of LLVM_ATTRIBUTE_NORETURN is kept for now.
This applies to memory accesses to (compile-time) constant addresses
(such as memory-mapped registers). Currently when a misaligned access
to such an address is detected, a fatal error is reported. This change
will emit a remark, and the compilation will continue with a trap,
and "undef" (for loads) emitted.
This fixes https://llvm.org/PR50838.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D50524
Same as other CreateLoad-style APIs, these need an explicit type
argument to support opaque pointers.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D105395
This is a mechanical change. This actually also renames the
similarly named methods in the SmallString class, however these
methods don't seem to be used outside of the llvm subproject, so
this doesn't break building of the rest of the monorepo.
Since this method can apply to cmpxchg operations, make sure it's clear
what value we're actually retrieving. This will help ensure we don't
accidentally ignore the failure ordering of cmpxchg in the future.
We could potentially introduce a getOrdering() method on AtomicSDNode
that asserts the operation isn't cmpxchg, but not sure that's
worthwhile.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D103338
Don't require a specific kind of IRBuilder for TargetLowering hooks.
This allows us to drop the IRBuilder.h include from TargetLowering.h.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D103759
When you try to define a new DEBUG_TYPE in a header file, DEBUG_TYPE
definition defined around the #includes in files include it could
result in redefinition warnings even compile errors.
Reviewed By: tejohnson
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D102594
Passing template parameter packs to std::map doesn't work in VS 2017/2019, so this updates the preprocessor version check to use an alternate version in VS2019, as well.
Reviewed By: DavidSpickett
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D102260
getVectorNumElements() returns a value for scalable vectors
without any warning so it is effectively getVectorMinNumElements().
By renaming it and making getVectorNumElements() forward to
it, we can insert a check for scalable vectors into getVectorNumElements()
similar to EVT. I didn't do that in this patch because there are still more
fixes needed, but I was able to temporarily do it and passed the RISCV
lit tests with these changes.
The changes to isPow2VectorType and getPow2VectorType are copied from EVT.
The change to TypeInfer::EnforceSameNumElts reduces the size of AArch64's isel table.
We're now considering SameNumElts to require the scalable property to match which
removes some unneeded type checks.
This was motivated by the bug I fixed yesterday in 80b9510806
Reviewed By: frasercrmck, sdesmalen
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D102262
Printing pass manager invocations is fairly verbose and not super
useful.
This allows us to remove DebugLogging from pass managers and PassBuilder
since all logging (aside from analysis managers) goes through
instrumentation now.
This has the downside of never being able to print the top level pass
manager via instrumentation, but that seems like a minor downside.
Reviewed By: ychen
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D101797
Deleted HexagonMapAsm2IntrinV65.gen.td that wasn't included anywhere,
moved V6_vrmpy*_rtt* patterns to HexagonIntrinsics.td.
Touch CMakeLists.txt to force re-cmake (somehow the unused file was
listed as a dependency in the generated makefiles).
'not' expands to checking for an xor with a -1 constant. Since
this looks for a ConstantSDNode it will never match for a vector.
Co-authored-by: Craig Topper <craig.topper@sifive.com>
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D100687
Intrinsics for the following instructions are added. The intrinsic
name is "int_hexagon_<inst>[_128B]", e.g.
int_hexagon_V6_vL32b_pred_ai for 64-byte version
int_hexagon_V6_vL32b_pred_ai_128B for 128-byte version
V6_vL32b_pred_ai if (Pv4) Vd32 = vmem(Rt32+#s4)
V6_vL32b_pred_pi if (Pv4) Vd32 = vmem(Rx32++#s3)
V6_vL32b_pred_ppu if (Pv4) Vd32 = vmem(Rx32++Mu2)
V6_vL32b_npred_ai if (!Pv4) Vd32 = vmem(Rt32+#s4)
V6_vL32b_npred_pi if (!Pv4) Vd32 = vmem(Rx32++#s3)
V6_vL32b_npred_ppu if (!Pv4) Vd32 = vmem(Rx32++Mu2)
V6_vL32b_nt_pred_ai if (Pv4) Vd32 = vmem(Rt32+#s4):nt
V6_vL32b_nt_pred_pi if (Pv4) Vd32 = vmem(Rx32++#s3):nt
V6_vL32b_nt_pred_ppu if (Pv4) Vd32 = vmem(Rx32++Mu2):nt
V6_vL32b_nt_npred_ai if (!Pv4) Vd32 = vmem(Rt32+#s4):nt
V6_vL32b_nt_npred_pi if (!Pv4) Vd32 = vmem(Rx32++#s3):nt
V6_vL32b_nt_npred_ppu if (!Pv4) Vd32 = vmem(Rx32++Mu2):nt
V6_vS32b_pred_ai if (Pv4) vmem(Rt32+#s4) = Vs32
V6_vS32b_pred_pi if (Pv4) vmem(Rx32++#s3) = Vs32
V6_vS32b_pred_ppu if (Pv4) vmem(Rx32++Mu2) = Vs32
V6_vS32b_npred_ai if (!Pv4) vmem(Rt32+#s4) = Vs32
V6_vS32b_npred_pi if (!Pv4) vmem(Rx32++#s3) = Vs32
V6_vS32b_npred_ppu if (!Pv4) vmem(Rx32++Mu2) = Vs32
V6_vS32Ub_pred_ai if (Pv4) vmemu(Rt32+#s4) = Vs32
V6_vS32Ub_pred_pi if (Pv4) vmemu(Rx32++#s3) = Vs32
V6_vS32Ub_pred_ppu if (Pv4) vmemu(Rx32++Mu2) = Vs32
V6_vS32Ub_npred_ai if (!Pv4) vmemu(Rt32+#s4) = Vs32
V6_vS32Ub_npred_pi if (!Pv4) vmemu(Rx32++#s3) = Vs32
V6_vS32Ub_npred_ppu if (!Pv4) vmemu(Rx32++Mu2) = Vs32
V6_vS32b_nt_pred_ai if (Pv4) vmem(Rt32+#s4):nt = Vs32
V6_vS32b_nt_pred_pi if (Pv4) vmem(Rx32++#s3):nt = Vs32
V6_vS32b_nt_pred_ppu if (Pv4) vmem(Rx32++Mu2):nt = Vs32
V6_vS32b_nt_npred_ai if (!Pv4) vmem(Rt32+#s4):nt = Vs32
V6_vS32b_nt_npred_pi if (!Pv4) vmem(Rx32++#s3):nt = Vs32
V6_vS32b_nt_npred_ppu if (!Pv4) vmem(Rx32++Mu2):nt = Vs32
These constraints are machine agnostic; there's no reason to handle
these per-arch. If arches don't support these constraints, then they
will fail elsewhere during instruction selection. We don't need virtual
calls to look these up; TargetLowering::getInlineAsmMemConstraint should
only be overridden by architectures with additional unique memory
constraints.
Reviewed By: echristo, MaskRay
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D100416
Such attributes can either be unset, or set to "true" or "false" (as string).
throughout the codebase, this led to inelegant checks ranging from
if (Fn->getFnAttribute("no-jump-tables").getValueAsString() == "true")
to
if (Fn->hasAttribute("no-jump-tables") && Fn->getFnAttribute("no-jump-tables").getValueAsString() == "true")
Introduce a getValueAsBool that normalize the check, with the following
behavior:
no attributes or attribute set to "false" => return false
attribute set to "true" => return true
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D99299
Added cost estimation for switch instruction, updated costs of branches, fixed
phi cost.
Had to increase `-amdgpu-unroll-threshold-if` default value since conditional
branch cost (size) was corrected to higher value.
Test renamed to "control-flow.ll".
Removed redundant code in `X86TTIImpl::getCFInstrCost()` and
`PPCTTIImpl::getCFInstrCost()`.
Reviewed By: rampitec
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D96805
Main reason is preparation to transform AliasResult to class that contains
offset for PartialAlias case.
Reviewed By: asbirlea
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D98027
Looking at the Doxygen-generated documentation for the llvm namespace
currently shows all sorts of random comments from different parts of the
codebase. These are mostly caused by:
- File doc comments that aren't marked with \file, so they're attached to
the next declaration, which is usually "namespace llvm {".
- Class doc comments placed before the namespace rather than before the
class.
- Code comments before the namespace that (in my opinion) shouldn't be
extracted by doxygen at all.
This commit fixes these comments. The generated doxygen documentation now
has proper docs for several classes and files, and the docs for the llvm
and llvm::detail namespaces are now empty.
Reviewed By: thakis, mizvekov
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D96736
Currently needsStackRealignment returns false if canRealignStack returns false.
This means that the behavior of needsStackRealignment does not correspond to
it's name and description; a function might need stack realignment, but if it
is not possible then this function returns false. Furthermore,
needsStackRealignment is not virtual and therefore some backends have made use
of canRealignStack to indicate whether a function needs stack realignment.
This patch attempts to clarify the situation by separating them and introducing
new names:
- shouldRealignStack - true if there is any reason the stack should be
realigned
- canRealignStack - true if we are still able to realign the stack (e.g. we
can still reserve/have reserved a frame pointer)
- hasStackRealignment = shouldRealignStack && canRealignStack (not target
customisable)
Targets can now override shouldRealignStack to indicate that stack realignment
is required.
This change will make it easier in a future change to handle the case where we
need to realign the stack but can't do so (for example when the register
allocator creates an aligned spill after the frame pointer has been
eliminated).
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D98716
Change-Id: Ib9a4d21728bf9d08a545b4365418d3ffe1af4d87
This patch changes the interface to take a RegisterKind, to indicate
whether the register bitwidth of a scalar register, fixed-width vector
register, or scalable vector register must be returned.
Reviewed By: paulwalker-arm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D98874
As far as I can tell, the node coming in has an i64 result so the
return should have the same type. The HexagonISD node used for
this has a type profile that says the result is i64.
Found while trying to add assserts to LegalizeDAG to catch
result type mismatches.
Reviewed By: kparzysz
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D98962
The offset in HVX loads/stores is only 4 bits long, so often an
extra register is needed to hold the address. Minimize the number
of such registers by "standardizing" the base addresses and reusing
preexisting base registers when replacing frame indices.
This adds an Mask ArrayRef to getShuffleCost, so that if an exact mask
can be provided a more accurate cost can be provided by the backend.
For example VREV costs could be returned by the ARM backend. This should
be an NFC until then, laying the groundwork for that to be added.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D98206
As a followup to D95291, getOperandsScalarizationOverhead was still
using a VF as a vector factor if the arguments were scalar, and would
assert on certain matrix intrinsics with differently sized vector
arguments. This patch removes the VF arg, instead passing the Types
through directly. This should allow it to more accurately compute the
cost without having to guess at which operands will be vectorized,
something difficult with more complex intrinsics.
This adjusts one SVE test as it is now calling the wrong intrinsic vs
veccall. Without invalid InstructCosts the cost of the scalarized
intrinsic is too low. This should get fixed when the cost of
scalarization is accounted for with scalable types.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D96287
This refactors shouldFavorPostInc() and shouldFavorBackedgeIndex() into
getPreferredAddressingMode() so that we have one interface to steer LSR in
generating the preferred addressing mode.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D96600
This will be needed in the loop-vectorizer where the minimum VF
requested may be a scalable VF. getMinimumVF now takes an additional
operand 'IsScalableVF' that indicates whether a scalable VF is required.
Reviewed By: kparzysz, rampitec
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D96020
The Hexagon Vector Combine pass genertes stores for a complete
aligned vector. The start of each section is a multiple of the
vector size, so that value is passed to normalize to compute
the offset of the stores in the section. The first store may
not occur at offset 0 when there is a gap between sections.
The result cannot be widened, unfortunately, because widening vNi1
would depend on the context in which it appears (i.e. the type alone
is not sufficient to tell if it needs to be widened).
This patch fixes a bug that could result in miscompiles (at least
in an OOT target). The problem could be seen by adding checks that
the DominatorTree used in BasicAliasAnalysis and ValueTracking was
valid (e.g. by adding DT->verify() call before every DT dereference
and then running all tests in test/CodeGen).
Problem was that the LegacyPassManager calculated "last user"
incorrectly for passes such as the DominatorTree when not telling
the pass manager that there was a transitive dependency between
the different analyses. And then it could happen that an incorrect
dominator tree was used when doing alias analysis (which was a pretty
serious bug as the alias analysis result could be invalid).
Fixes: https://bugs.llvm.org/show_bug.cgi?id=48709
Reviewed By: nikic
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D94138
In https://reviews.llvm.org/D88138 this was incorrectly added with
registerOptimizerLastEPCallback(), when it should be
registerLoopOptimizerEndEPCallback(), matching the legacy PM's
EP_LoopOptimizerEnd.
Reviewed By: rnk
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D93929
As mentioned in D93793, there are quite a few places where unary `IRBuilder::CreateShuffleVector(X, Mask)` can be used
instead of `IRBuilder::CreateShuffleVector(X, Undef, Mask)`.
Let's update them.
Actually, it would have been more natural if the patches were made in this order:
(1) let them use unary CreateShuffleVector first
(2) update IRBuilder::CreateShuffleVector to use poison as a placeholder value (D93793)
The order is swapped, but in terms of correctness it is still fine.
Reviewed By: spatel
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D93923
My bot runs VS 2019, but it could not compile this code.
Message:
[55/2465] Building CXX object lib\Target\Hexagon\CMakeFiles\LLVMHexagonCodeGen.dir\HexagonVectorCombine.cpp.obj
FAILED: lib/Target/Hexagon/CMakeFiles/LLVMHexagonCodeGen.dir/HexagonVectorCombine.cpp.obj
...
C:\Program Files (x86)\Microsoft Visual Studio\2019\Professional\VC\Tools\MSVC\14.23.28105\include\map(71): error C2976: 'std::map': too few template arguments
C:\Program Files (x86)\Microsoft Visual Studio\2019\Professional\VC\Tools\MSVC\14.23.28105\include\map(71): note: see declaration of 'std::map'
The version in the path, 14.23, corresponds to _MSC_VER 1923, so raise
the version floor to 1924.
I have not tested with versions between 1924 and 1928 (latest), but the
latest works with the variadic version.
Brendon Cahoon