Summary:
Currently the DbgValueHistorymap only keeps track of clobbered registers
for the last debug value that it has encountered. This could lead to
preceding register-described debug values living on longer in the
location lists than they should. See PR40283 for an example. This
patch does not introduce tracking of multiple registers, but changes
the DbgValueHistoryMap structure to allow for that in a follow-up
patch. This patch is not NFC, as it at least fixes two bugs in
DwarfDebug (both are covered in the new clobbered-fragments.mir test):
* If a debug value was clobbered (its End pointer set), the value would
still be added to OpenRanges, meaning that the succeeding location list
entries could potentially contain stale values.
* If a debug value was clobbered, and there were non-overlapping
fragments that were still live after the clobbering, DwarfDebug would
not create a location list entry starting directly after the
clobbering instruction. This meant that the location list could have
a gap until the next debug value for the variable was encountered.
Before this patch, the history map was represented by <Begin, End>
pairs, where a new pair was created for each new debug value. When
dealing with partially overlapping register-described debug values, such
as in the following example:
DBG_VALUE $reg2, $noreg, !1, !DIExpression(DW_OP_LLVM_fragment, 32, 32)
[...]
DBG_VALUE $reg3, $noreg, !1, !DIExpression(DW_OP_LLVM_fragment, 64, 32)
[...]
$reg2 = insn1
[...]
$reg3 = insn2
the history map would then contain the entries `[<DV1, insn1>, [<DV2, insn2>]`.
This would leave it up to the users of the map to be aware of
the relative order of the instructions, which e.g. could make
DwarfDebug::buildLocationList() needlessly complex. Instead, this patch
makes the history map structure monotonically increasing by dropping the
End pointer, and replacing that with explicit clobbering entries in the
vector. Each debug value has an "end index", which if set, points to the
entry in the vector that ends the debug value. The ending entry can
either be an overlapping debug value, or an instruction which clobbers
the register that the debug value is described by. The ending entry's
instruction can thus either be excluded or included in the debug value's
range. If the end index is not set, the debug value that the entry
introduces is valid until the end of the function.
Changes to test cases:
* DebugInfo/X86/pieces-3.ll: The range of the first DBG_VALUE, which
describes that the fragment (0, 64) is located in RDI, was
incorrectly ended by the clobbering of RAX, which the second
(non-overlapping) DBG_VALUE was described by. With this patch we
get a second entry that only describes RDI after that clobbering.
* DebugInfo/ARM/partial-subreg.ll: This test seems to indiciate a bug
in LiveDebugValues that is caused by it not being aware of fragments.
I have added some comments in the test case about that. Also, before
this patch DwarfDebug would incorrectly include a register-described
debug value from a preceding block in a location list entry.
Reviewers: aprantl, probinson, dblaikie, rnk, bjope
Reviewed By: aprantl
Subscribers: javed.absar, kristof.beyls, jdoerfert, llvm-commits
Tags: #debug-info, #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D59941
llvm-svn: 358072
Summary:
In an upcoming commit the history map will be changed so that it
contains explicit entries for instructions that clobber preceding debug
values, rather than Begin- End range pairs, so generalize the name to
"Entry".
Also, prefix the iterator variable names in buildLocationList() with
"E". In an upcoming commit the entry will have query functions such as
"isD(e)b(u)gValue", which could at a glance make one confuse it for
iterations over MachineInstrs, so make the iterator names a bit more
distinct to avoid that.
Reviewers: aprantl
Reviewed By: aprantl
Subscribers: llvm-commits
Tags: #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D59939
llvm-svn: 358060
Summary:
Replace use of std::pair by creating a class for the debug value
instruction ranges instead. This is a preparatory refactoring for
improving handling of clobbered fragments.
In an upcoming commit the Begin pointer will become a PointerIntPair, so
it will be cleaner to have a getter for that.
Reviewers: aprantl
Subscribers: llvm-commits
Tags: #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D59938
llvm-svn: 358059
Summary:
With MergeValues() removed, amend DebugLocEntry's constructor so that it
takes multiple values rather than a single, and keep non-fragment values
in OpenRanges, as this allows some cleanup of the code in
buildLocationList().
Reviewers: aprantl, dblaikie, loladiro
Reviewed By: aprantl
Subscribers: hiraditya, llvm-commits
Tags: #debug-info, #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D59303
llvm-svn: 357988
Summary:
The MergeValues() function would try to merge two entries if they shared
the same beginning label. Having the same beginning label means that the
former entry's range would be empty; however, after D55919 we no longer
create entries for empty ranges, so we can no longer land in a situation
where that check in MergeValues would succeed. Instead, the "merging" is
done by keeping the live values from the preceding empty ranges in
OpenRanges, and adding them to the first non-empty range.
Reviewers: aprantl, dblaikie, loladiro
Reviewed By: aprantl
Subscribers: llvm-commits
Tags: #debug-info, #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D59301
llvm-svn: 357974
This reverts commit rL357020.
The commit broke the test llvm/test/tools/llvm-objdump/embedded-source.test
on some builds including clang-ppc64be-linux-multistage,
clang-s390x-linux, clang-with-lto-ubuntu, clang-x64-windows-msvc,
llvm-clang-lld-x86_64-scei-ps4-windows10pro-fast (and others).
llvm-svn: 357026
Reapply rL356941 after regenerating the object file in the failing test
llvm/test/tools/llvm-objdump/embedded-source.test from source.
Original commit message:
[llvm] Prevent duplicate files in debug line header in dwarf 5.
Motivation: In previous dwarf versions, file name indexes started from 1, and
the primary source file was not explicit. Dwarf 5 standard (6.2.4) prescribes
the primary source file to be explicitly given an entry with an index number 0.
The current implementation honors the specification by just duplicating the
main source file, once with index number 0, and later maybe with another
index number. While this is compliant with the letter of the standard, the
duplication causes problems for consumers of this information such as lldb.
(Some files are duplicated, where only some of them have a line table although
all refer to the same file)
With this change, dwarf 5 debug line section files always start from 0, and
the zeroth entry is not duplicated whenever possible. This requires different
handling of dwarf 4 and dwarf 5 during generation (e.g. when a function returns
an index zero for a file name, it signals an error in dwarf 4, but not in dwarf 5)
However, I think the minor complication is worth it, because it enables all
consumers (lldb, gdb, dwarfdump, objdump, and so on) to treat all files in the
file name list homogenously.
Tags: #llvm, #debug-info
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D59515
llvm-svn: 357018
Summary:
Motivation: In previous dwarf versions, file name indexes started from 1, and
the primary source file was not explicit. Dwarf 5 standard (6.2.4) prescribes
the primary source file to be explicitly given an entry with an index number 0.
The current implementation honors the specification by just duplicating the
main source file, once with index number 0, and later maybe with another
index number. While this is compliant with the letter of the standard, the
duplication causes problems for consumers of this information such as lldb.
(Some files are duplicated, where only some of them have a line table although
all refer to the same file)
With this change, dwarf 5 debug line section files always start from 0, and
the zeroth entry is not duplicated whenever possible. This requires different
handling of dwarf 4 and dwarf 5 during generation (e.g. when a function returns
an index zero for a file name, it signals an error in dwarf 4, but not in dwarf 5)
However, I think the minor complication is worth it, because it enables all
consumers (lldb, gdb, dwarfdump, objdump, and so on) to treat all files in the
file name list homogenously.
Reviewers: dblaikie, probinson, aprantl, espindola
Reviewed By: probinson
Subscribers: emaste, jvesely, nhaehnle, aprantl, javed.absar, arichardson, hiraditya, MaskRay, rupprecht, jdoerfert, llvm-commits
Tags: #llvm, #debug-info
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D59515
llvm-svn: 356941
Nothing prevents entries from being bigger than the 16 bit size field in
Dwarf < 5. For entries that are too big, just emit an empty entry
instead of crashing.
This fixes PR41038.
Reviewers: probinson, aprantl, davide
Reviewed By: probinson
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D59518
llvm-svn: 356514
Introduce a DW_OP_LLVM_convert Dwarf expression pseudo op that allows
for a convenient way to perform type conversions on the Dwarf expression
stack. As an additional bonus it paves the way for using other Dwarf
v5 ops that need to reference a base_type.
The new DW_OP_LLVM_convert is used from lib/Transforms/Utils/Local.cpp
to perform sext/zext on debug values but mainly the patch is about
preparing terrain for adding other Dwarf v5 ops that need to reference a
base_type.
For Dwarf v5 the op maps to DW_OP_convert and for earlier versions a
complex shift & mask pattern is generated to emulate sext/zext.
This is a recommit of r356442 with trivial fixes for the failing tests.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D56587
llvm-svn: 356451
Introduce a DW_OP_LLVM_convert Dwarf expression pseudo op that allows
for a convenient way to perform type conversions on the Dwarf expression
stack. As an additional bonus it paves the way for using other Dwarf
v5 ops that need to reference a base_type.
The new DW_OP_LLVM_convert is used from lib/Transforms/Utils/Local.cpp
to perform sext/zext on debug values but mainly the patch is about
preparing terrain for adding other Dwarf v5 ops that need to reference a
base_type.
For Dwarf v5 the op maps to DW_OP_convert and for earlier versions a
complex shift & mask pattern is generated to emulate sext/zext.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D56587
llvm-svn: 356442
This configuration (due to r349207) was intended not to emit any DWO CU,
but a degenerate CU was still being emitted - containing a header and a
DW_TAG_compile_unit with no attributes.
Under that situation, emit nothing to the .dwo file. (since this is a
dynamic property of the input the .dwo file is still emitted, just with
nothing in it (so a valid, but empty, ELF file) - if some other CU
didn't satisfy this criteria, its DWO CU would still go there, etc)
llvm-svn: 353771
Summary: Initial function labels must follow the debug location for the correct relocation info generation.
Reviewers: tra, jlebar, echristo
Subscribers: jholewinski, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45784
llvm-svn: 351843
to reflect the new license.
We understand that people may be surprised that we're moving the header
entirely to discuss the new license. We checked this carefully with the
Foundation's lawyer and we believe this is the correct approach.
Essentially, all code in the project is now made available by the LLVM
project under our new license, so you will see that the license headers
include that license only. Some of our contributors have contributed
code under our old license, and accordingly, we have retained a copy of
our old license notice in the top-level files in each project and
repository.
llvm-svn: 351636
Currently we do not always collapse subsequent .loc 0 0 directives. The
reason is that we were checking for a PrevInstLoc which is not set when
we emit a line-0 record. We should only check the LastAsmLine, which
seems to be created exactly for this purpose.
// When we emit a line-0 record, we don't update PrevInstLoc; so look at
// the last line number actually emitted, to see if it was line 0.
unsigned LastAsmLine =
Asm->OutStreamer->getContext().getCurrentDwarfLoc().getLine();
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D56767
llvm-svn: 351395
Summary:
This fixes PR39710. In that case we emitted a location list looking like
this:
.Ldebug_loc0:
.quad .Lfunc_begin0-.Lfunc_begin0
.quad .Lfunc_begin0-.Lfunc_begin0
.short 1 # Loc expr size
.byte 85 # DW_OP_reg5
.quad .Lfunc_begin0-.Lfunc_begin0
.quad .Lfunc_end0-.Lfunc_begin0
.short 1 # Loc expr size
.byte 85 # super-register DW_OP_reg5
.quad 0
.quad 0
As seen, the first entry's beginning and ending addresses evalute to 0,
which meant that the entry inadvertently became an "end of list" entry,
resulting in the location list ending sooner than expected.
To fix this, omit all entries with empty ranges. Location list entries
with empty ranges do not have any effect, as specified by DWARF, so we
might as well drop them:
"A location list entry (but not a base address selection or end of list
entry) whose beginning and ending addresses are equal has no effect
because the size of the range covered by such an entry is zero."
Reviewers: davide, aprantl, dblaikie
Reviewed By: aprantl
Subscribers: javed.absar, JDevlieghere, llvm-commits
Tags: #debug-info
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D55919
llvm-svn: 350698
When deciding lazily whether a CU would be split or non-split I
accidentally dropped some handling for the line tables comp_dir (by
doing it lazily it was too late to be handled properly by the MC line
table code).
Move that bit of the code back to the non-lazy place.
llvm-svn: 349819
In ThinLTO many split CUs may be effectively empty because of the lack
of support for cross-unit references in split DWARF.
Using a split unit in those cases is just a waste/overhead - and turned
out to be one contributor to a significant symbolizer performance issue
when global variable debug info was being imported (see r348416 for the
primary fix) due to symbolizers seeing CUs with no ranges, assuming
there might still be addresses covered and walking into the split CU to
see if there are any ranges (when that split CU was in a DWP file, that
meant loading the DWP and its index, the index was extra large because
of all these fractured/empty CUs... and so was very expensive to load).
(the 3rd fix which will follow, is to assume that a CU with no ranges is
empty rather than merely missing its CU level range data - and to not
walk into its DIEs (split or otherwise) in search of address information
that is generally not present)
llvm-svn: 349207
Summary:
The comment refers to the field as "Kind:". However, in gdb,
https://sourceware.org/gdb//onlinedocs/gdb/Index-Section-Format.html names it "attributes",
gdb/dwarf2read.c:dw2_symtab_iter_next refers to the whole value as "cu_index_and_attrs"
Change it to `Attributes:` for consistency.
Reviewers: dblaikie
Reviewed By: dblaikie
Subscribers: aprantl, JDevlieghere, arphaman, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D54480
llvm-svn: 346790
Summary:
Ranges base address specifiers can save a lot of object size in
relocation records especially in optimized builds.
For an optimized self-host build of Clang with split DWARF and debug
info compression in object files, but uncompressed debug info in the
executable, this change produces about 18% smaller object files and 6%
larger executable.
While it would've been nice to turn this on by default, gold's 32 bit
gdb-index support crashes on this input & I don't think there's any
perfect heuristic to implement solely in LLVM that would suffice - so
we'll need a flag one way or another (also possible people might want to
aggressively optimized for executable size that contains debug info
(even with compression this would still come at some cost to executable
size)) - so let's plumb it through.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D54242
llvm-svn: 346788
Turns out knowing more than just the base address might be useful -
specifically a future change to respect a DICompileUnit flag for the use
of base address specifiers in DWARF < 5.
llvm-svn: 346380
Before this patch DbgInfoAvailable was set to true in
DwarfDebug::beginModule() or CodeViewDebug::CodeViewDebug(). This made
MIR testing weird since passes would suddenly stop dealing with debug
info just because we stopped the pipeline before the debug printers.
This patch changes the logic to initialize DbgInfoAvailable based on the
fact that debug_compile_units exist in the llvm Module. The debug
printers may then override it with false in case of debug printing being
disabled.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D53885
llvm-svn: 345740
.debug_loclists is the DWARF 5 version of the .debug_loc.
With that patch, it will be emitted when DWARF 5 is used.
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D53365
llvm-svn: 345377
This isn't the most object-size efficient encoding, but it's the only
one GDB supports for the pre-standard fission format. I've written fixes
for this twice now... - so perhaps this comment will help me remember
why neither of these have been committed and why I shouldn't try to
write a third fix another year from now...
llvm-svn: 345326
This makes the offsets larger (since they are further from the base
address) but those are in the .dwo - and allows removing addresses and
relocations from the .o file.
This could be built into the AddressPool more fundamentally, perhaps -
when you ask for an AddressPool entry you could say "or give me some
other entry and an offset I need to use" - though what to do about
situations where the first use of an address in a section is not the
earliest address in that section... is tricky.
At least with range addresses we can be fairly sure we've seen the
earliest address first because we see the start address for the
function.
llvm-svn: 345224
Logs provided by @stella.stamenova indicate that on Linux, lldb adds a
spurious slide offset to the return PC it loads from AT_call_return_pc
attributes (see the list thread: "[PATCH] D50478: Add support for
artificial tail call frames").
This patch side-steps the issue by getting rid of the load address
calculation in lldb's CallEdge::GetReturnPCAddress.
The idea is to have the DWARF writer emit function-local offsets to the
instruction after a call. I.e. return-pc = label-after-call-insn -
function-entry. LLDB can simply add this offset to the base address of a
function to get the return PC.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D53469
llvm-svn: 344960
Using a base address specifier even for a single-element range is a size
win for object files (7 words versus 8 words - more significant savings
if the debug info is compressed (since it's 3 words of uncompressable
reloc + 4 compressable words compared to 6 uncompressable reloc + 2
compressable words) - does trade off executable size increase though.
llvm-svn: 344841
Putting addresses in the address pool, even with non-fission, can reduce
relocations - reusing the addresses from debug_info and debug_rnglists
(the latter coming soon)
llvm-svn: 344834
The initial patch was not reviewed, and does not have any tests;
it should not have been merged.
This reverts 344395, 344390, 344387, 344385, 344381, 344376,
and 344366.
llvm-svn: 344405
BTF is the debug format for BPF, a kernel virtual machine
and widely used for tracing, networking and security, etc ([1]).
Currently only instruction streams are passed to kernel,
the kernel verifier verifies them before execution. In order to
provide better visibility of bpf programs to user space
tools, some debug information, e.g., function names and
debug line information are desirable for kernel so tools
can get such information with better annotation
for jited instructions for performance or other reasons.
The dwarf is too complicated in kernel and for BPF.
Hence, BTF is designed to be the debug format for BPF ([2]).
Right now, pahole supports BTF for types, which
are generated based on dwarf sections in the ELF file.
In order to annotate performance metrics for jited bpf insns,
it is necessary to pass debug line info to the kernel.
Furthermore, we want to pass the actual code to the
kernel because of the following reasons:
. bpf program typically is small so storage overhead
should be small.
. in bpf land, it is totally possible that
an application loads the bpf program into the
kernel and then that application quits, so
holding debug info by the user space application
is not practical.
. having source codes directly kept by kernel
would ease deployment since the original source
code does not need ship on every hosts and
kernel-devel package does not need to be
deployed even if kernel headers are used.
The only reliable time to get the source code is
during compilation time. This will result in both more
accurate information and easier deployment as
stated in the above.
Another consideration is for JIT. The project like bcc
use MCJIT to compile a C program into bpf insns and
load them to the kernel ([3]). The generated BTF sections
will be readily available for such cases as well.
This patch implemented generation of BTF info in llvm
compiler. The BTF related sections will be generated
when both -target bpf and -g are specified. Two sections
are generated:
.BTF contains all the type and string information, and
.BTF.ext contains the func_info and line_info.
The separation is related to how two sections are used
differently in bpf loader, e.g., linux libbpf ([4]).
The .BTF section can be loaded into the kernel directly
while .BTF.ext needs loader manipulation before loading
to the kernel. The format of the each section is roughly
defined in llvm:include/llvm/MC/MCBTFContext.h and
from the implementation in llvm:lib/MC/MCBTFContext.cpp.
A later example also shows the contents in each section.
The type and func_info are gathered during CodeGen/AsmPrinter
by traversing dwarf debug_info. The line_info is
gathered in MCObjectStreamer before writing to
the object file. After all the information is gathered,
the two sections are emitted in MCObjectStreamer::finishImpl.
With cmake CMAKE_BUILD_TYPE=Debug, the compiler can
dump out all the tables except insn offset, which
will be resolved later as relocation records.
The debug type "btf" is used for BTFContext dump.
Dwarf tests the debug info generation with
llvm-dwarfdump to decode the binary sections and
check whether the result is expected. Currently
we do not have such a tool yet. We will implement
btf dump functionality in bpftool ([5]) as the bpftool is
considered the recommended tool for bpf introspection.
The implementation for type and func_info is tested
with linux kernel test cases. The line_info is visually
checked with dump from linux kernel libbpf ([4]) and
checked with readelf dumping section raw data.
Note that the .BTF and .BTF.ext information will not
be emitted to assembly code and there is no assembler
support for BTF either.
In the below, with a clang/llvm built with CMAKE_BUILD_TYPE=Debug,
Each table contents are shown for a simple C program.
-bash-4.2$ cat -n test.c
1 struct A {
2 int a;
3 char b;
4 };
5
6 int test(struct A *t) {
7 return t->a;
8 }
-bash-4.2$ clang -O2 -target bpf -g -mllvm -debug-only=btf -c test.c
Type Table:
[1] FUNC name_off=1 info=0x0c000001 size/type=2
param_type=3
[2] INT name_off=12 info=0x01000000 size/type=4
desc=0x01000020
[3] PTR name_off=0 info=0x02000000 size/type=4
[4] STRUCT name_off=16 info=0x04000002 size/type=8
name_off=18 type=2 bit_offset=0
name_off=20 type=5 bit_offset=32
[5] INT name_off=22 info=0x01000000 size/type=1
desc=0x02000008
String Table:
0 :
1 : test
6 : .text
12 : int
16 : A
18 : a
20 : b
22 : char
27 : test.c
34 : int test(struct A *t) {
58 : return t->a;
FuncInfo Table:
sec_name_off=6
insn_offset=<Omitted> type_id=1
LineInfo Table:
sec_name_off=6
insn_offset=<Omitted> file_name_off=27 line_off=34 line_num=6 column_num=0
insn_offset=<Omitted> file_name_off=27 line_off=58 line_num=7 column_num=3
-bash-4.2$ readelf -S test.o
......
[12] .BTF PROGBITS 0000000000000000 0000028d
00000000000000c1 0000000000000000 0 0 1
[13] .BTF.ext PROGBITS 0000000000000000 0000034e
0000000000000050 0000000000000000 0 0 1
[14] .rel.BTF.ext REL 0000000000000000 00000648
0000000000000030 0000000000000010 16 13 8
......
-bash-4.2$
The latest linux kernel ([6]) can already support .BTF with type information.
The [7] has the reference implementation in linux kernel side
to support .BTF.ext func_info. The .BTF.ext line_info support is not
implemented yet. If you have difficulty accessing [6], you can
manually do the following to access the code:
git clone https://github.com/yonghong-song/bpf-next-linux.git
cd bpf-next-linux
git checkout btf
The change will push to linux kernel soon once this patch is landed.
References:
[1]. https://www.kernel.org/doc/Documentation/networking/filter.txt
[2]. https://lwn.net/Articles/750695/
[3]. https://github.com/iovisor/bcc
[4]. https://github.com/torvalds/linux/tree/master/tools/lib/bpf
[5]. https://github.com/torvalds/linux/tree/master/tools/bpf/bpftool
[6]. https://github.com/torvalds/linux
[7]. https://github.com/yonghong-song/bpf-next-linux/tree/btf
Signed-off-by: Song Liu <songliubraving@fb.com>
Signed-off-by: Yonghong Song <yhs@fb.com>
Acked-by: Alexei Starovoitov <ast@kernel.org>
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D52950
llvm-svn: 344366
It originally triggered a stepping problem in the debugger, which could
be fixed by adjusting CodeGen/LexicalScopes.cpp however it seems we prefer
the previous behavior anyway.
See the discussion for details: http://lists.llvm.org/pipermail/llvm-commits/Week-of-Mon-20181008/593833.html
This reverts commit r343880.
This reverts commit r343874.
llvm-svn: 344318
DWARF v5 introduces DW_AT_call_all_calls, a subprogram attribute which
indicates that all calls (both regular and tail) within the subprogram
have call site entries. The information within these call site entries
can be used by a debugger to populate backtraces with synthetic tail
call frames.
Tail calling frames go missing in backtraces because the frame of the
caller is reused by the callee. Call site entries allow a debugger to
reconstruct a sequence of (tail) calls which led from one function to
another. This improves backtrace quality. There are limitations: tail
recursion isn't handled, variables within synthetic frames may not
survive to be inspected, etc. This approach is not novel, see:
https://gcc.gnu.org/wiki/summit2010?action=AttachFile&do=get&target=jelinek.pdf
This patch adds an IR-level flag (DIFlagAllCallsDescribed) which lowers
to DW_AT_call_all_calls. It adds the minimal amount of DWARF generation
support needed to emit standards-compliant call site entries. For easier
deployment, when the debugger tuning is LLDB, the DWARF requirement is
adjusted to v4.
Testing: Apart from check-{llvm, clang}, I built a stage2 RelWithDebInfo
clang binary. Its dSYM passed verification and grew by 1.4% compared to
the baseline. 151,879 call site entries were added.
rdar://42001377
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49887
llvm-svn: 343883
Context: Compiler generated instructions do not have a debug location
assigned to them. However emitting 0-line records for all of them bloats
the line tables for very little benefit so we usually avoid doing that.
Not emitting anything will lead to the previous debug location getting
applied to the locationless instructions. This is not desirable for
block begin and after labels. Previously we would emit simply emit
line-0 records in this case, this patch changes the behavior to do a
forward search for a debug location in these cases before emitting a
line-0 record to further reduce line table bloat.
Inspired by the discussion in https://reviews.llvm.org/D52862
llvm-svn: 343874
Currently, we emit DW_AT_addr_base that points to the beginning of
the .debug_addr section. That is not correct for the DWARF5 case because address
table contains the header and the attribute should point to the first entry
following the header.
This is currently the reason why LLDB does not work with such executables correctly.
Patch fixes the issue.
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D52168
llvm-svn: 342635
std::vector::iterator type may be a pointer, then
iterator::value_type fails to compile since iterator is not a class,
namespace, or enumeration.
Patch by orivej (Orivej Desh)
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D52142
llvm-svn: 342354
In DwarfDebug::collectEntityInfo(), if the label entity is processed in
DbgLabels list, it means the label is not optimized out. There is no
need to generate debug info for it with null position.
llvm-svn: 341513
There are two forms for label debug information in DWARF format.
1. Labels in a non-inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_name
DW_AT_decl_file
DW_AT_decl_line
DW_AT_low_pc
2. Labels in an inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_abstract_origin
DW_AT_low_pc
We will collect label information from DBG_LABEL. Before every DBG_LABEL,
we will generate a temporary symbol to denote the location of the label.
The symbol could be used to get DW_AT_low_pc afterwards. So, we create a
mapping between 'inlined label' and DBG_LABEL MachineInstr in DebugHandlerBase.
The DBG_LABEL in the mapping is used to query the symbol before it.
The AbstractLabels in DwarfCompileUnit is used to process labels in inlined
functions.
We also keep a mapping between scope and labels in DwarfFile to help to
generate correct tree structure of DIEs.
It also generates label debug information under global isel.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45556
llvm-svn: 340039
In cases where the debugger load time is a worthwhile tradeoff (or less
costly - such as loading from a DWP instead of a variety of DWOs
(possibly over a high-latency/distributed filesystem)) against object
file size, it can be reasonable to disable pubnames and corresponding
gdb-index creation in the linker.
A backend-flag version of this was implemented for NVPTX in
D44385/r327994 - which was fine for NVPTX which wouldn't mix-and-match
CUs. Now that it's going to be a user-facing option (likely powered by
"-gno-pubnames", the same as GCC) it should be encoded in the
DICompileUnit so it can vary per-CU.
After this, likely the NVPTX support should be migrated to the metadata
& the previous flag implementation should be removed.
Reviewers: aprantl
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D50213
llvm-svn: 339939
There are two forms for label debug information in DWARF format.
1. Labels in a non-inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_name
DW_AT_decl_file
DW_AT_decl_line
DW_AT_low_pc
2. Labels in an inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_abstract_origin
DW_AT_low_pc
We will collect label information from DBG_LABEL. Before every DBG_LABEL,
we will generate a temporary symbol to denote the location of the label.
The symbol could be used to get DW_AT_low_pc afterwards. So, we create a
mapping between 'inlined label' and DBG_LABEL MachineInstr in DebugHandlerBase.
The DBG_LABEL in the mapping is used to query the symbol before it.
The AbstractLabels in DwarfCompileUnit is used to process labels in inlined
functions.
We also keep a mapping between scope and labels in DwarfFile to help to
generate correct tree structure of DIEs.
It also generates label debug information under global isel.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45556
llvm-svn: 339676
When using APPLE extensions, don't duplicate the compiler invocation's
flags both in AT_producer and AT_APPLE_flags.
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D50453
llvm-svn: 339268
Summary:
The accelerator tables use the debug_str section to store their strings.
However, they do not support the indirect method of access that is
available for the debug_info section (DW_FORM_strx et al.).
Currently our code is assuming that all strings can/will be referenced
indirectly, and puts all of them into the debug_str_offsets section.
This is generally true for regular (unsplit) dwarf, but in the DWO case,
most of the strings in the debug_str section will only be used from the
accelerator tables. Therefore the contents of the debug_str_offsets
section will be largely unused and bloating the main executable.
This patch rectifies this by teaching the DwarfStringPool to
differentiate between strings accessed directly and indirectly. When a
user inserts a string into the pool it has to declare whether that
string will be referenced directly or not. If at least one user requsts
indirect access, that string will be assigned an index ID and put into
debug_str_offsets table. Otherwise, the offset table is skipped.
This approach reduces the overall binary size (when compiled with
-gdwarf-5 -gsplit-dwarf) in my tests by about 2% (debug_str_offsets is
shrunk by 99%).
Reviewers: probinson, dblaikie, JDevlieghere
Subscribers: aprantl, mgrang, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49493
llvm-svn: 339122
Summary:
Added an option that allows to emit only '.loc' and '.file' kind debug
directives, but disables emission of the DWARF sections. Required for
NVPTX target to support profiling. It requires '.loc' and '.file'
directives, but does not require any DWARF sections for the profiler.
Reviewers: probinson, echristo, dblaikie
Subscribers: aprantl, JDevlieghere, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D46021
llvm-svn: 338616
Getting the DWARF types section is only implemented for ELF object
files. We already disabled emitting debug types in clang (r337717), but
now we also report an fatal error (rather than crashing) when trying to
obtain this section in MC. Additionally we ignore the generate debug
types flag for unsupported target triples.
See PR38190 for more information.
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D50057
llvm-svn: 338527
This revision implements support for generating DWARFv5 .debug_addr section.
The implementation is pretty straight-forward: we just check the dwarf version
and emit section header if needed.
Reviewers: aprantl, dblaikie, probinson
Reviewed by: dblaikie
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D50005
llvm-svn: 338487
There are two forms for label debug information in DWARF format.
1. Labels in a non-inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_name
DW_AT_decl_file
DW_AT_decl_line
DW_AT_low_pc
2. Labels in an inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_abstract_origin
DW_AT_low_pc
We will collect label information from DBG_LABEL. Before every DBG_LABEL,
we will generate a temporary symbol to denote the location of the label.
The symbol could be used to get DW_AT_low_pc afterwards. So, we create a
mapping between 'inlined label' and DBG_LABEL MachineInstr in DebugHandlerBase.
The DBG_LABEL in the mapping is used to query the symbol before it.
The AbstractLabels in DwarfCompileUnit is used to process labels in inlined
functions.
We also keep a mapping between scope and labels in DwarfFile to help to
generate correct tree structure of DIEs.
It also generates label debug information under global isel.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45556
llvm-svn: 338390
The test failure was caused by the compiler not emitting a __debug_ranges section with DWARF 4 and
earlier when no ranges are needed. The test checks for the existence regardless.
llvm-svn: 338081
Previous version of this patch failed on darwin targets because of
different handling of cross-debug-section relocations. This fixes the
tests to emit the DW_AT_str_offsets_base attribute correctly in both
cases. Since doing this is a non-trivial amount of code, and I'm going
to need it in more than one test, I've added a helper function to the
dwarfgen DIE class to do it.
Original commit message follows:
The motivation for this is D49493, where we'd like to test details of
debug_str_offsets behavior which is difficult to trigger from a
traditional test.
This adds the plubming necessary for dwarfgen to generate this section.
The more interesting changes are:
- I've moved emitStringOffsetsTableHeader function from DwarfFile to
DwarfStringPool, so I can generate the section header more easily from
the unit test.
- added a new addAttribute overload taking an MCExpr*. This is used to
generate the DW_AT_str_offsets_base, which links a compile unit to the
offset table.
I've also added a basic test for reading and writing DW_form_strx forms.
Reviewers: dblaikie, JDevlieghere, probinson
Subscribers: llvm-commits, aprantl
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49670
llvm-svn: 338031
This recommits r337910 after fixing an "ambiguous call to addAttribute"
error with some compilers (gcc circa 4.9 and MSVC). It seems that these
compilers will consider a "false -> pointer" conversion during overload
resolution. This creates ambiguity because one I added an overload which
takes a MCExpr * as an argument.
I fix this by making the new overload take MCExpr&, which avoids the
conversion. It also documents the fact that we expect a valid MCExpr
object.
Original commit message follows:
The motivation for this is D49493, where we'd like to test details of
debug_str_offsets behavior which is difficult to trigger from a
traditional test.
This adds the plubming necessary for dwarfgen to generate this section.
The more interesting changes are:
- I've moved emitStringOffsetsTableHeader function from DwarfFile to
DwarfStringPool, so I can generate the section header more easily from
the unit test.
- added a new addAttribute overload taking an MCExpr*. This is used to
generate the DW_AT_str_offsets_base, which links a compile unit to the
offset table.
I've also added a basic test for reading and writing DW_form_strx forms.
Reviewers: dblaikie, JDevlieghere, probinson
Subscribers: llvm-commits, aprantl
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49670
llvm-svn: 337933
This reverts commit r337910 as it's generating "ambiguous call to
addAttribute" errors on some bots.
Will resubmit once I get a chance to look into the problem.
llvm-svn: 337924
Summary:
The motivation for this is D49493, where we'd like to test details of
debug_str_offsets behavior which is difficult to trigger from a
traditional test.
This adds the plubming necessary for dwarfgen to generate this section.
The more interesting changes are:
- I've moved emitStringOffsetsTableHeader function from DwarfFile to
DwarfStringPool, so I can generate the section header more easily from
the unit test.
- added a new addAttribute overload taking an MCExpr*. This is used to
generate the DW_AT_str_offsets_base, which links a compile unit to the
offset table.
I've also added a basic test for reading and writing DW_form_strx forms.
Reviewers: dblaikie, JDevlieghere, probinson
Subscribers: llvm-commits, aprantl
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49670
llvm-svn: 337910
There are two forms for label debug information in DWARF format.
1. Labels in a non-inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_name
DW_AT_decl_file
DW_AT_decl_line
DW_AT_low_pc
2. Labels in an inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_abstract_origin
DW_AT_low_pc
We will collect label information from DBG_LABEL. Before every DBG_LABEL,
we will generate a temporary symbol to denote the location of the label.
The symbol could be used to get DW_AT_low_pc afterwards. So, we create a
mapping between 'inlined label' and DBG_LABEL MachineInstr in DebugHandlerBase.
The DBG_LABEL in the mapping is used to query the symbol before it.
The AbstractLabels in DwarfCompileUnit is used to process labels in inlined
functions.
We also keep a mapping between scope and labels in DwarfFile to help to
generate correct tree structure of DIEs.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45556
Patch by Hsiangkai Wang.
llvm-svn: 337799
Summary:
Each of the four methods had a dozen lines and was doing almost exactly
the same thing: get the appropriate accelerator table kind and insert an
entry into it. I move this common logic to a helper function and make
these methods delegate to it.
This came up in the context of D49493, where I've needed to make adding
a string to a string pool slightly more complicated, and it seemed to
make sense to do it in one place instead of five.
To make this work I've needed to unify the interface of the AccelTable
data types, as some used to store DIE& and others DIE*. I chose to unify
to a reference as that's what the caller uses.
This technically isn't NFC, because it changes the StringPool used for
apple tables in the DWO case (now it uses the main file like DWARF v5
instead of the DWO file). However, that shouldn't matter, as DWO is not
a thing on apple targets (clang frontend simply ignores -gsplit-dwarf).
Reviewers: JDevlieghere, aprantl, probinson
Subscribers: llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49542
llvm-svn: 337562
Summary:
This patch makes us generate the debug_names section in response to some
user-facing commands (previously it was only generated if explicitly
selected via the -accel-tables option).
My goal was to make this work for DWARF>=5 (as it's an official part of
that standard), and also, as an extension, for DWARF<5 if one is
explicitly tuning for lldb as a debugger (because it brings a large
performance improvement there).
This is slightly complicated by the fact that the debug_names tables are
incompatible with the DWARF v4 type units (they assume that the type
units are in the debug_info section), and unfortunately, right now we
generate DWARF v4-style type units even for -gdwarf-5. For this reason,
I disable all accelerator tables if the user requested type unit
generation. I do this even for apple tables, as they have the same
problem (in fact generating type units for apple targets makes us crash
even before we get around to emitting the accelerator tables).
Reviewers: JDevlieghere, aprantl, dblaikie, echristo, probinson
Subscribers: llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49420
llvm-svn: 337544
Since DWARFv5 rnglists are self descriptive and have distinct encodings
for base-relative (offset_pair) and absolute (start_length) entries,
there's no need to use a base address specifier when describing a lone
address range in a section.
Use that, and improve the test coverage a bit here to include cases like
this and others.
llvm-svn: 337411
and no use of DW_FORM_rnglistx with the DW_AT_ranges attribute.
Reviewer: aprantl
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49214
llvm-svn: 336927
This is prep for DWARF v5 range list emission. Emission of a single range list is moved
to a static helper function.
Reviewer: jdevlieghere
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49098
llvm-svn: 336621
Summary:
.debug_loc section is not supported for NVPTX target. If there is an
object whose location can change during its lifetime, we do not generate
debug location info for this variable.
Reviewers: echristo
Subscribers: jholewinski, JDevlieghere, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D48730
llvm-svn: 335976
Remove unused ByteStreamer argument from function emitDebugLocValue.
Patch by Nikola Prica.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D48590
llvm-svn: 335811
In DWARF v5, the DWO ID is in the (split/skeleton) CU header, not an
attribute on the CU DIE.
This changes the size of those headers, so use the parsed size whenever
we have one, for simplicitly.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D47158
llvm-svn: 333004
This reapplies commits: r330271, r330592, r330779.
[DEBUG] Initial adaptation of NVPTX target for debug info emission.
Summary:
Patch adds initial emission of the debug info for NVPTX target.
Currently, only .file and .loc directives are emitted, everything else is
commented out to not break the compilation of Cuda.
llvm-svn: 332689
Summary:
If we are not emitting a linkage name in the .debug_info sections, we
should not add it into the index either. This makes sure our index is
consistent with the actual debug info.
I am also explicitly setting the --dwarf-linkage-names=All in the
name-collsions test as that one would now fail on targets where this
defaults to "Abstract" (in fact, it would have failed already if there
wasn't a bug in the DWARF verifier, which I fix as well).
Reviewers: probinson, aprantl, JDevlieghere
Subscribers: llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D46748
llvm-svn: 332246
The DEBUG() macro is very generic so it might clash with other projects.
The renaming was done as follows:
- git grep -l 'DEBUG' | xargs sed -i 's/\bDEBUG\s\?(/LLVM_DEBUG(/g'
- git diff -U0 master | ../clang/tools/clang-format/clang-format-diff.py -i -p1 -style LLVM
- Manual change to APInt
- Manually chage DOCS as regex doesn't match it.
In the transition period the DEBUG() macro is still present and aliased
to the LLVM_DEBUG() one.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D43624
llvm-svn: 332240
In order to set breakpoints on labels and list source code around
labels, we need collect debug information for labels, i.e., label
name, the function label belong, line number in the file, and the
address label located. In order to keep these information in LLVM
IR and to allow backend to generate debug information correctly.
We create a new kind of metadata for labels, DILabel. The format
of DILabel is
!DILabel(scope: !1, name: "foo", file: !2, line: 3)
We hope to keep debug information as much as possible even the
code is optimized. So, we create a new kind of intrinsic for label
metadata to avoid the metadata is eliminated with basic block.
The intrinsic will keep existing if we keep it from optimized out.
The format of the intrinsic is
llvm.dbg.label(metadata !1)
It has only one argument, that is the DILabel metadata. The
intrinsic will follow the label immediately. Backend could get the
label metadata through the intrinsic's parameter.
We also create DIBuilder API for labels to be used by Frontend.
Frontend could use createLabel() to allocate DILabel objects, and use
insertLabel() to insert llvm.dbg.label intrinsic in LLVM IR.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45024
Patch by Hsiangkai Wang.
llvm-svn: 331841
We've been running doxygen with the autobrief option for a couple of
years now. This makes the \brief markers into our comments
redundant. Since they are a visual distraction and we don't want to
encourage more \brief markers in new code either, this patch removes
them all.
Patch produced by
for i in $(git grep -l '\\brief'); do perl -pi -e 's/\\brief //g' $i & done
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D46290
llvm-svn: 331272
This appears to have some issues associated with the file directive output
causing multiple global symbols with the name "file" to be emitted into a
startup section. I'm investigating more specific causes and working with the
original author.
This reverts commit r330271.
Also Revert "[DEBUGINFO, NVPTX] Add the test for the debug info of the local"
This reverts commit r330592 and the follow up of 330779 as the testcase is dependent upon r330271.
llvm-svn: 331237
Summary:
Patch adds initial emission of the debug info for NVPTX target.
Currently, only .file and .loc directives are emitted, everything else is
commented out to not break the compilation of Cuda.
Reviewers: echristo, jlebar, tra, jholewinski
Subscribers: mgorny, aprantl, JDevlieghere, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D41827
llvm-svn: 330271
Summary:
Previously we crashed for the combination of the two features because we
tried to reference the dwo CU from the main object file. The fix
consists of two items:
- reference the skeleton CU from the name index (the consumer is
expected to use the skeleton CU to find the real data).
- use the main object file string pool for the strings in the index
Reviewers: JDevlieghere, aprantl, dblaikie
Subscribers: llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45566
llvm-svn: 330249
Summary:
If an input DICompileUnit is completely empty (e.g., the result of
running "clang -g" on an empty file), we don't bother emitting an empty
DWARF CU. When we do that, we must make sure we don't also emit a DWARF v5
name index, as DWARF specifies that each index must reference at least
one compilation unit.
Reviewers: JDevlieghere, aprantl, dblaikie
Subscribers: llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45435
llvm-svn: 329575
Summary:
We were emitting accelerator entries for functions with no name, which
is contrary to the DWARF v5 spec: "All other (i.e., *not*
DW_TAG_namespace) debugging information entries without a DW_AT_name
attribute are excluded." Besides that, a name table entry with an empty
string as a key is fairly useless.
We can sometimes end up with functions which have a DW_AT_linkage_name but no
DW_AT_name. One such example is the global-constructor-initialization functions,
which C++ compilers synthesize for each compilation unit with global
constructors.
A very strict reading of the DWARF v5 spec would suggest that we should not even
emit the accelerator entry for the linkage name in this case, but I don't think
we should go that far.
I found this when running the dwarf verifier over llvm codebase compiled
with DWARF v5 accelerator tables.
Reviewers: JDevlieghere, aprantl, dblaikie
Subscribers: vleschuk, clayborg, echristo, probinson, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45367
llvm-svn: 329552
Summary:
r327219 added wrappers to std::sort which randomly shuffle the container before sorting.
This will help in uncovering non-determinism caused due to undefined sorting
order of objects having the same key.
To make use of that infrastructure we need to invoke llvm::sort instead of std::sort.
Note: This patch is one of a series of patches to replace *all* std::sort to llvm::sort.
Refer the comments section in D44363 for a list of all the required patches.
Reviewers: bogner, rnk, MatzeB, RKSimon
Reviewed By: rnk
Subscribers: JDevlieghere, javed.absar, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45133
llvm-svn: 329435
Some compilers do not like having an enum type and a variable with the
same name (AccelTableKind). I rename the variable to TheAccelTableKind.
Suggestions for a better name welcome.
llvm-svn: 329202
- MSVC was not OK with a static_assert referencing a non-static member
variable, even though it was just in a sizeof(expression). I move the
assert into the emit function, where it is probably more useful.
- Tests were failing in builds which did not have the X86 target
configured. Since this functionality is not target-specific, I have
removed the target specifiers from the .ll files.
llvm-svn: 329201
Summary:
This patch adds a DwarfAccelTableEmitter class, which generates an
accelerator table, as specified in DWARF v5 standard. At the moment it
only generates a DIE offset column and (if we are indexing more than one
compile unit) a CU column.
Indexing type units is not currently supported, as we don't even have
the ability to generate DWARF v5-compatible compile units.
The implementation is not data-source agnostic like the one generating
apple tables. This was not necessary as we currently only have one user
of this code, and without a second user it was not obvious to me how to
best abstract this. (The difference between these tables and the apple
ones is that they need a lot more metadata about the debug info they are
indexing).
The generation is triggered by the --accel-tables argument, which
supersedes the --dwarf-accel-tables arg -- the latter was a simple
on-off switch, but not we can choose between two kinds of accelerator
tables we can generate.
This is tested by parsing the generated tables with llvm-dwarfdump and
the DWARFVerifier, and I've also checked that GNU readelf is able to
make sense of the tables.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D43286
llvm-svn: 329179
DWARF v5 specifies that the root file (also given in the DW_AT_name
attribute of the compilation unit DIE) should be emitted explicitly to
the line table's list of files. This makes the line table more
independent of the .debug_info section.
We emit the new syntax only for DWARF v5 and later.
Fixes the bug found by asan. Also XFAIL the new test for Darwin, which
is stuck on DWARF v2, and fix up other tests so they stop failing on
Windows. Last but not least, don't break "clang -g" of an assembler
file that has .file directives in it.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D44054
llvm-svn: 328805
This reverts commit r328676.
Commit r328676 broke the -no-integrated-as flag necessary to build Linux kernel with Clang:
$ cat t.c
void foo() {}
$ clang -no-integrated-as -c t.c -g
/tmp/t-dcdec5.s: Assembler messages:
/tmp/t-dcdec5.s:8: Error: file number less than one
clang-7.0: error: assembler command failed with exit code 1 (use -v to see invocation)
llvm-svn: 328699
DWARF v5 specifies that the root file (also given in the DW_AT_name
attribute of the compilation unit DIE) should be emitted explicitly to
the line table's list of files. This makes the line table more
independent of the .debug_info section.
Fixes the bug found by asan. Also XFAIL the new test for Darwin, which
is stuck on DWARF v2, and fix up other tests so they stop failing on
Windows. Last but not least, don't break "clang -g" of an assembler
file that has .file directives in it.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D44054
llvm-svn: 328676
If a given split type unit does not have source locations, don't have
it refer to the split line table.
If no split type unit refers to the split line table, don't emit the
line table at all.
This will save a little space on rare occasions, but also refactors
things a bit to improve which class is responsible for what.
Responding to review comments on r326395.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D44220
llvm-svn: 328670
Summary:
Some targets does not support labels inside debug sections, but support
references in form `section+offset`. Patch adds initial support
for this.
Reviewers: echristo, probinson, jlebar
Subscribers: llvm-commits, JDevlieghere
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D43943
llvm-svn: 328314
David Stenberg