Confirmed with Craig Topper - fix a typo that was missing a Port4 uop for ROR*mCL instructions on some Intel models.
Yet another step on the scheduler model cleanup marathon......
llvm-svn: 342846
The SandyBridge model was missing schedule values for the RCL/RCR values - instead using the (incredibly optimistic) WriteShift (now WriteRotate) defaults.
I've added overrides with more realistic (slow) values, based on a mixture of Agner/instlatx64 numbers and what later Intel models do as well.
This is necessary to allow WriteRotate to be updated to remove other rotate overrides.
It'd probably be a good idea to investigate a WriteRotateCarry class at some point but its not high priority given the unusualness of these instructions.
llvm-svn: 342842
This patch introduces a SchedWriteVariant to describe zero-idiom VXORP(S|D)Yrr
and VANDNP(S|D)Yrr.
This is a follow-up of r342555.
On Jaguar, a VXORPSYrr is 2 macro opcodes. Only one opcode is eliminated at
register-renaming stage. The other opcode has to be executed to set the upper
half of the destination YMM.
Same for VANDNP(S|D)Yrr.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D52347
llvm-svn: 342728
This patch adds the ability for processor models to describe dependency breaking
instructions.
Different processors may specify a different set of dependency-breaking
instructions.
That means, we cannot assume that all processors of the same target would use
the same rules to classify dependency breaking instructions.
The main goal of this patch is to provide the means to describe dependency
breaking instructions directly via tablegen, and have the following
TargetSubtargetInfo hooks redefined in overrides by tabegen'd
XXXGenSubtargetInfo classes (here, XXX is a Target name).
```
virtual bool isZeroIdiom(const MachineInstr *MI, APInt &Mask) const {
return false;
}
virtual bool isDependencyBreaking(const MachineInstr *MI, APInt &Mask) const {
return isZeroIdiom(MI);
}
```
An instruction MI is a dependency-breaking instruction if a call to method
isDependencyBreaking(MI) on the STI (TargetSubtargetInfo object) evaluates to
true. Similarly, an instruction MI is a special case of zero-idiom dependency
breaking instruction if a call to STI.isZeroIdiom(MI) returns true.
The extra APInt is used for those targets that may want to select which machine
operands have their dependency broken (see comments in code).
Note that by default, subtargets don't know about the existence of
dependency-breaking. In the absence of external information, those method calls
would always return false.
A new tablegen class named STIPredicate has been added by this patch to let
processor models classify instructions that have properties in common. The idea
is that, a MCInstrPredicate definition can be used to "generate" an instruction
equivalence class, with the idea that instructions of a same class all have a
property in common.
STIPredicate definitions are essentially a collection of instruction equivalence
classes.
Also, different processor models can specify a different variant of the same
STIPredicate with different rules (i.e. predicates) to classify instructions.
Tablegen backends (in this particular case, the SubtargetEmitter) will be able
to process STIPredicate definitions, and automatically generate functions in
XXXGenSubtargetInfo.
This patch introduces two special kind of STIPredicate classes named
IsZeroIdiomFunction and IsDepBreakingFunction in tablegen. It also adds a
definition for those in the BtVer2 scheduling model only.
This patch supersedes the one committed at r338372 (phabricator review: D49310).
The main advantages are:
- We can describe subtarget predicates via tablegen using STIPredicates.
- We can describe zero-idioms / dep-breaking instructions directly via
tablegen in the scheduling models.
In future, the STIPredicates framework can be used for solving other problems.
Examples of future developments are:
- Teach how to identify optimizable register-register moves
- Teach how to identify slow LEA instructions (each subtarget defining its own
concept of "slow" LEA).
- Teach how to identify instructions that have undocumented false dependencies
on the output registers on some processors only.
It is also (in my opinion) an elegant way to expose knowledge to both external
tools like llvm-mca, and codegen passes.
For example, machine schedulers in LLVM could reuse that information when
internally constructing the data dependency graph for a code region.
This new design feature is also an "opt-in" feature. Processor models don't have
to use the new STIPredicates. It has all been designed to be as unintrusive as
possible.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D52174
llvm-svn: 342555
A ReadAdvance was incorrectly added to the SchedReadWrite list associated with
the following SSE instructions:
sqrtss
sqrtsd
rsqrtss
rcpss
As a consequence, a wrong operand latency was computed for the register operand
used as the base address of the folded load operand.
This patch removes the wrong ReadAdvance, and updates the llvm-mca test cases.
There is still a problem with correctly modeling partial register writes on XMM
registers This other problem is currently tracked here:
https://bugs.llvm.org/show_bug.cgi?id=38813
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D51542
llvm-svn: 341326
The presence of a ReadAdvance for input operand #0 is problematic
because it changes the input latency of the register used as the base address
for the folded load.
A broadcast cannot start executing if the load address hasn't been computed yet.
In the llvm-mca example, the VBROADCASTSS is dependent on the address generated
by the LEAQ. That means, it cannot start until LEAQ reaches the write-back
stage. If we apply ReadAdvance, then we wrongly assume that the load can start 3
cycles in advance.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D51534
llvm-svn: 341222
According to the timeline view, sqrtss/sd/rcpss start executing before the load
address for the memory operand is available.
This problem is caused by the presence of a ReadAfterLd (a ReadAdvance). Those
unary operations should not specify a ReadAdvance at all.
llvm-svn: 341213
This patch fixes the number of micro opcodes, and processor resource cycles for
the following AVX instructions:
vinsertf128rr/rm
vperm2f128rr/rm
vbroadcastf128
Tests have been regenerated using the usual scripts in the llvm/utils directory.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D51492
llvm-svn: 341185
This patch introduces the following changes to the DispatchStatistics view:
* DispatchStatistics now reports the number of dispatched opcodes instead of
the number of dispatched instructions.
* The "Dynamic Dispatch Stall Cycles" table now also reports the percentage of
stall cycles against the total simulated cycles.
This change allows users to easily compare dispatch group sizes with the
processor DispatchWidth.
Before this change, it was difficult to correlate the two numbers, since
DispatchStatistics view reported numbers of instructions (instead of opcodes).
DispatchWidth defines the maximum size of a dispatch group in terms of number of
micro opcodes.
The other change introduced by this patch is related to how DispatchStage
generates "instruction dispatch" events.
In particular:
* There can be multiple dispatch events associated with a same instruction
* Each dispatch event now encapsulates the number of dispatched micro opcodes.
The number of micro opcodes declared by an instruction may exceed the processor
DispatchWidth. Therefore, we cannot assume that instructions are always fully
dispatched in a single cycle.
DispatchStage knows already how to handle instructions declaring a number of
opcodes bigger that DispatchWidth. However, DispatchStage always emitted a
single instruction dispatch event (during the first simulated dispatch cycle)
for instructions dispatched.
With this patch, DispatchStage now correctly notifies multiple dispatch events
for instructions that cannot be dispatched in a single cycle.
A few views had to be modified. Views can no longer assume that there can only
be one dispatch event per instruction.
Tests (and docs) have been updated.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D51430
llvm-svn: 341055
This patch adds two new fields to the perf report generated by the SummaryView.
Fields are now logically organized into two small groups; only the second group
contains throughput indicators.
Example:
```
Iterations: 100
Instructions: 300
Total Cycles: 414
Total uOps: 700
Dispatch Width: 4
uOps Per Cycle: 1.69
IPC: 0.72
Block RThroughput: 4.0
```
This patch also updates the docs for llvm-mca.
Due to the nature of this change, several tests in the tools/llvm-mca directory
were affected, and had to be updated using script `update_mca_test_checks.py`.
llvm-svn: 340946
This patch also uses colors to highlight problematic wait-time entries.
A problematic entry is an entry with an high wait time that tends to match (or
exceed) the size of the scheduler's buffer.
Color RED is used if an instruction had to wait an average number of cycles
which is bigger than (or equal to) the size of the underlying scheduler's
buffer.
Color YELLOW is used if the time (in cycles) spend waiting for the
operands or pipeline resources is bigger than half the size of the underlying
scheduler's buffer.
Color MAGENTA is used if an instruction does not consume buffer resources
according to the scheduling model.
llvm-svn: 340825
Before this patch, the SchedulerStatistics only printed the maximum number of
buffer entries consumed in each scheduler's queue at a given point of the
simulation.
This patch restructures the reported table, and adds an extra field named
"Average number of used buffer entries" to it.
This patch also uses different colors to help identifying bottlenecks caused by
high scheduler's buffer pressure.
llvm-svn: 340746
This patch fixes a regression introduced at revision 338702.
A processor resource mask was incorrectly implicitly truncated to an unsigned
quantity. Later on, the truncated mask was used to initialize an element of a
vector of processor resource descriptors.
On targets with more than 32 processor resources, some elements of the vector
are left uninitialized. As a consequence, this bug might have eventually caused
a crash due to null dereference in the Scheduler.
This patch fixes PR38575, and adds a test for it.
llvm-svn: 339768
I've put CMPXCHG8B/CMPXCHG16B in the same file, even though technically they are under separate CPUID bits all targets seem to support both (or neither).
llvm-svn: 338595
These aren't exhaustive, but cover some instructions that are only available in 32-bit mode (where would we be without good BCD math performance?).
llvm-svn: 338404
This patch teaches llvm-mca how to identify dependency breaking instructions on
btver2.
An example of dependency breaking instructions is the zero-idiom XOR (example:
`XOR %eax, %eax`), which always generates zero regardless of the actual value of
the input register operands.
Dependency breaking instructions don't have to wait on their input register
operands before executing. This is because the computation is not dependent on
the inputs.
Not all dependency breaking idioms are also zero-latency instructions. For
example, `CMPEQ %xmm1, %xmm1` is independent on
the value of XMM1, and it generates a vector of all-ones.
That instruction is not eliminated at register renaming stage, and its opcode is
issued to a pipeline for execution. So, the latency is not zero.
This patch adds a new method named isDependencyBreaking() to the MCInstrAnalysis
interface. That method takes as input an instruction (i.e. MCInst) and a
MCSubtargetInfo.
The default implementation of isDependencyBreaking() conservatively returns
false for all instructions. Targets may override the default behavior for
specific CPUs, and return a value which better matches the subtarget behavior.
In future, we should teach to Tablegen how to automatically generate the body of
isDependencyBreaking from scheduling predicate definitions. This would allow us
to expose the knowledge about dependency breaking instructions to the machine
schedulers (and, potentially, other codegen passes).
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49310
llvm-svn: 338372
Summary:
Pretty mechanical follow-up for D49196.
As microarchitecture.pdf notes, "20 AMD Ryzen pipeline",
"20.8 Register renaming and out-of-order schedulers":
The integer register file has 168 physical registers of 64 bits each.
The floating point register file has 160 registers of 128 bits each.
"20.14 Partial register access":
The processor always keeps the different parts of an integer register together.
...
An instruction that writes to part of a register will therefore have a false dependence
on any previous write to the same register or any part of it.
Reviewers: andreadb, courbet, RKSimon, craig.topper, GGanesh
Reviewed By: GGanesh
Subscribers: gbedwell, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49393
llvm-svn: 337676
This patch fixes the latency/throughput of LEA instructions in the BtVer2
scheduling model.
On Jaguar, A 3-operands LEA has a latency of 2cy, and a reciprocal throughput of
1. That is because it uses one cycle of SAGU followed by 1cy of ALU1. An LEA
with a "Scale" operand is also slow, and it has the same latency profile as the
3-operands LEA. An LEA16r has a latency of 3cy, and a throughput of 0.5 (i.e.
RThrouhgput of 2.0).
This patch adds a new TIIPredicate named IsThreeOperandsLEAFn to X86Schedule.td.
The tablegen backend (for instruction-info) expands that definition into this
(file X86GenInstrInfo.inc):
```
static bool isThreeOperandsLEA(const MachineInstr &MI) {
return (
(
MI.getOpcode() == X86::LEA32r
|| MI.getOpcode() == X86::LEA64r
|| MI.getOpcode() == X86::LEA64_32r
|| MI.getOpcode() == X86::LEA16r
)
&& MI.getOperand(1).isReg()
&& MI.getOperand(1).getReg() != 0
&& MI.getOperand(3).isReg()
&& MI.getOperand(3).getReg() != 0
&& (
(
MI.getOperand(4).isImm()
&& MI.getOperand(4).getImm() != 0
)
|| (MI.getOperand(4).isGlobal())
)
);
}
```
A similar method is generated in the X86_MC namespace, and included into
X86MCTargetDesc.cpp (the declaration lives in X86MCTargetDesc.h).
Back to the BtVer2 scheduling model:
A new scheduling predicate named JSlowLEAPredicate now checks if either the
instruction is a three-operands LEA, or it is an LEA with a Scale value
different than 1.
A variant scheduling class uses that new predicate to correctly select the
appropriate latency profile.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49436
llvm-svn: 337469
Add llvm-mca tests demonstrating how LEA instructions are currently modelled. Once this is working on btver2 I'll copy the test file to the other target directories.
llvm-svn: 337297
registers.
The goal of this patch is to improve the throughput analysis in llvm-mca for the
case where instructions perform partial register writes.
On x86, partial register writes are quite difficult to model, mainly because
different processors tend to implement different register merging schemes in
hardware.
When the code contains partial register writes, the IPC (instructions per
cycles) estimated by llvm-mca tends to diverge quite significantly from the
observed IPC (using perf).
Modern AMD processors (at least, from Bulldozer onwards) don't rename partial
registers. Quoting Agner Fog's microarchitecture.pdf:
" The processor always keeps the different parts of an integer register together.
For example, AL and AH are not treated as independent by the out-of-order
execution mechanism. An instruction that writes to part of a register will
therefore have a false dependence on any previous write to the same register or
any part of it."
This patch is a first important step towards improving the analysis of partial
register updates. It changes the semantic of RegisterFile descriptors in
tablegen, and teaches llvm-mca how to identify false dependences in the presence
of partial register writes (for more details: see the new code comments in
include/Target/TargetSchedule.h - class RegisterFile).
This patch doesn't address the case where a write to a part of a register is
followed by a read from the whole register. On Intel chips, high8 registers
(AH/BH/CH/DH)) can be stored in separate physical registers. However, a later
(dirty) read of the full register (example: AX/EAX) triggers a merge uOp, which
adds extra latency (and potentially affects the pipe usage).
This is a very interesting article on the subject with a very informative answer
from Peter Cordes:
https://stackoverflow.com/questions/45660139/how-exactly-do-partial-registers-on-haswell-skylake-perform-writing-al-seems-to
In future, the definition of RegisterFile can be extended with extra information
that may be used to identify delays caused by merge opcodes triggered by a dirty
read of a partial write.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49196
llvm-svn: 337123
Before revision 336728, the "mayLoad" flag for instruction (V)MOVLPSrm was
inferred directly from the "default" pattern associated with the instruction
definition.
r336728 removed special node X86Movlps, and all the patterns associated to it.
Now instruction (V)MOVLPSrm doesn't have a pattern associated to it, and the
'mayLoad/hasSideEffects' flags are left unset.
When the instruction info is emitted by tablegen, method
CodeGenDAGPatterns::InferInstructionFlags() sees that (V)MOVLPSrm doesn't have a
pattern, and flags are undefined. So, it conservatively sets the
"hasSideEffects" flag for it.
As a consequence, we were losing the 'mayLoad' flag, and we were gaining a
'hasSideEffect' flag in its place.
This patch fixes the issue (originally reported by Michael Holmen).
The mca tests show the differences in the instruction info flags. Instructions
that were affected by this problem were: MOVLPSrm/VMOVLPSrm/VMOVLPSZ128rm.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D49182
llvm-svn: 336818
This makes easier to identify changes in the instruction info flags. It also
helps spotting potential regressions similar to the one recently introduced at
r336728.
Using the same character to mark MayLoad/MayStore/HasSideEffects is problematic
for llvm-lit. When pattern matching substrings, llvm-lit consumes tabs and
spaces. A change in position of the flag marker may not trigger a test failure.
This patch only changes the character used for flag `hasSideEffects`. The reason
why I didn't touch other flags is because I want to avoid spamming the mailing
because of the massive diff due to the numerous tests affected by this change.
In future, each instruction flag should be associated with a different character
in the Instruction Info View.
llvm-svn: 336797
llvm-mca doesn't know that on modern AMD processors, portions of a general
purpose register are not treated independently. So, a partial register write has
a false dependency on the super-register.
The issue with partial register writes will be addressed by a follow-up patch.
llvm-svn: 336778
This is a short-term fix for PR38093.
For now, we llvm::report_fatal_error if the instruction builder finds an
unsupported instruction in the instruction stream.
We need to revisit this fix once we start addressing PR38101.
Essentially, we need a better framework for error handling.
llvm-svn: 336543
This patch modifies the Scheduler heuristic used to select the next instruction
to issue to the pipelines.
The motivating example is test X86/BtVer2/add-sequence.s, for which llvm-mca
wrongly reported an estimated IPC of 1.50. According to perf, the actual IPC for
that test should have been ~2.00.
It turns out that an IPC of 2.00 for test add-sequence.s cannot possibly be
predicted by a Scheduler that only prioritizes instructions based on their
"age". A similar issue also affected test X86/BtVer2/dependent-pmuld-paddd.s,
for which llvm-mca wrongly estimated an IPC of 0.84 instead of an IPC of 1.00.
Instructions in the ReadyQueue are now ranked based on two factors:
- The "age" of an instruction.
- The number of unique users of writes associated with an instruction.
The new logic still prioritizes older instructions over younger instructions to
minimize the pressure on the reorder buffer. However, the number of users of an
instruction now also affects the overall rank. This potentially increases the
ability of the Scheduler to extract instruction level parallelism. This patch
fixes the problem with the wrong IPC reported for test add-sequence.s and test
dependent-pmuld-paddd.s.
llvm-svn: 336420
Simon Pilgrim